Litwin & Smith, A Law Corporation
Contact Us For A Free
10-Minute Telephone Call
View Our Practice Areas

CA9 to Rehear En Banc Case Involving Constitutionality of "Habitual Drunkard" Bar to Good Moral Character

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ordered that Ledezma-Cosino v. Lynch, originally decided by a three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit on 3/24/16, be reheard en banc. (Ledezma-Cosino v. Lynch, 10/12/16).

The [three-judge] panel granted Salomon Ledezma-Cosino's petition for review of the Board of Immigration Appeals' decision finding him ineligible for cancellation of removal or voluntary departure because he lacked good moral character as a "habitual drunkard" under 8 U.S.C. § 1101(f)(1).

The panel held that Ledezma-Cosino is barred from raising a due process claim, but he could bring an equal protection challenge because it does not require a liberty interest. The panel held that § 1101(f)(1) is unconstitutional under the Equal Protection Clause because there is no rational basis to classify people afflicted by chronic alcoholism as innately lacking good moral character. The panel remanded for further proceedings in light of the opinion.

Dissenting, Judge Clifton wrote that the opinion disregards the legal standard to be applied, and that § 1101(f)(1) should easily clear the very low bar of the rational basis test. Judge Clifton would find that the majority opinion includes several false legal premises, and it relies upon the false factual dichotomy that diagnosis of chronic alcoholism as "medical" means there can be no element of drunkenness subject to free will or susceptible to a moral evaluation.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
  • Experience Icon



    Years Experience

  • Employers Icon



  • Countries Icon



  • Approval Rating Icon



    Approval Rating

  • ABA Defending Liberty Pursuing Justice
  • Christian Legal Society
  • Avvo | Clients' Choice 2020 | Immigration
  • American Immigration Lawyers Association
  • The Bar Association of San Francisco
  • Federal Bar Association
  • Avvo Clients Choice | Award 2018 | Donald Edward Smith
  • Super Lawyers
  • Best Immigration Lawyers in San Francisco
Email Us For A Response

Schedule A Consultation

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Santa Clara Office
5201 Great America Parkway,
Suite 320
Santa Clara, CA 95054

Toll Free: 888-344-0892
Phone: 650-588-7100
Phone: 408-998-1159
Fax: 650-588-4302
Santa Clara Law Office Map

South San Francisco Office
1435 Huntington Ave, Suite 336
South San Francisco, CA 94080

Toll Free: 888-344-0892
Fax: 650-588-4302
South San Francisco Law Office Map

Map Map

Phone Numbers